98 lines
20 KiB
Markdown
98 lines
20 KiB
Markdown
# Crime, Immigration & Policing
|
||
|
||
*Part of [President Trump Fact Check](../README.md). Last updated October 29, 2026.*
|
||
|
||
---
|
||
|
||
### B8. "Democrats defunded the police / are soft on crime; Dem cities are crime-ridden."
|
||
|
||
**Verdict:** MOSTLY FALSE. A minority of cities made real but mostly modest and temporary cuts in 2020; nearly all were reversed by 2022; Biden explicitly opposed defunding; and per-capita murder rates have run *higher* in red states than blue states for over two decades.
|
||
|
||
**What's actually right about this (steelman):**
|
||
There is a true core. In summer 2020, at least a dozen major cities cut police funding or officer counts amid the "defund" movement: Minneapolis shifted ~$8 million (and moved $11.4 million to a restricted reserve) from a ~$179 million police budget; Los Angeles cut $150 million; Austin made the largest percentage cut in Bloomberg's 50-city analysis; New York cut roughly $1 billion from a ~$6 billion NYPD budget (mostly via accounting shifts); Portland cut millions in June 2020. Several high-crime cities — Chicago, Baltimore, New Orleans, St. Louis, Philadelphia — are Democratic-run with genuinely elevated homicide rates. Some progressive prosecutors (e.g., in Fairfax County, per a 2026 House Judiciary report) have drawn criticism for declining to prosecute certain cases. Activist Democrats did champion "defund the police" in 2020.
|
||
|
||
**Key facts:**
|
||
- By 2021–2022, nearly every cutting city had restored or exceeded prior funding: NYC added $200 million back; LA approved a 3% increase the year after its $150 million cut; Austin restored its budget "to new heights"; Portland added $5.2 million back to a $230 million budget; by the 2022 budget Minneapolis PD "had more cash on hand than before George Floyd's murder" — [NBC News, Dec 28, 2021](https://www.nbcnews.com/news/nbcblk/cities-vowed-2020-cut-police-funding-budgets-expanded-2021-rcna9864); [Chicago Tribune, Oct 11, 2021](https://www.chicagotribune.com/2021/10/11/a-year-after-defund-police-departments-get-their-money-back); [PBS NewsHour](https://www.pbs.org/newshour/amp/nation/portland-among-u-s-cities-adding-funds-to-police-departments)
|
||
- Bloomberg's review of 50-city budgets for FY 2021: most communities increased police funding or left it flat; the biggest *increases* were Tampa, Fresno, San Diego — [Bloomberg, 2021](https://www.bloomberg.com/graphics/2021-city-budget-police-funding)
|
||
- Joe Biden repeatedly said he does not support defunding the police (2020 campaign onward), and urged cities to use American Rescue Plan funds to *add* police funding — [NBC News, Dec 2021](https://www.nbcnews.com/news/nbcblk/cities-vowed-2020-cut-police-funding-budgets-expanded-2021-rcna9864)
|
||
- Red-state murder rates exceeded blue-state rates every year from 2000 through 2022; the gap was 33% higher in red states in both 2021 and 2022 (9.0 vs 6.8 per 100k in 2021; 8.5 vs 6.4 in 2022), per CDC death-certificate data — [Third Way, "The 21st Century Red State Murder Crisis"](https://www.thirdway.org/report/the-21st-century-red-state-murder-crisis)
|
||
- 8 of the 10 highest-murder-rate states in 2022 voted Trump in 2016 and 2020; Mississippi, Louisiana, Alabama held the top three rates for 15 of 23 years — [Third Way](https://www.thirdway.org/report/the-21st-century-red-state-murder-crisis)
|
||
- Removing the largest blue city's county from each red state (while keeping blue-state cities in) still left red-state murder rates 20% higher in 2021 and 16% higher in 2022 — refuting the "it's just their blue cities" rejoinder — [Third Way](https://www.thirdway.org/report/the-21st-century-red-state-murder-crisis)
|
||
- Over 2000–2020 combined, per-capita murder was 23% higher in Trump-voting states; red-state rates rose 39.4% over two decades vs. 13.4% in blue states — [Third Way, "The Two-Decade Red State Murder Problem"](https://www.thirdway.org/report/the-two-decade-red-state-murder-problem)
|
||
|
||
**Rebuttal / context to raise in conversation:**
|
||
"Democrats defunded the police" describes about a year of activist pressure (2020–21) that produced modest, mostly reversible trims in roughly a dozen cities — followed by restoration almost everywhere by 2022, often to record levels, pushed by Democratic mayors citing rising crime. The Democratic president opposed defunding throughout and told cities to spend federal relief money on police. Meanwhile the "Dem cities are crime-ridden" frame inverts the state-level data: using CDC mortality data (which unlike FBI reporting is mandatory for all states), Trump-voting states have had higher per-capita murder rates than Biden-voting states every single year this century — a 23-year streak — with Mississippi, Louisiana, and Alabama as the persistent top three. The retort "that's because of blue cities in red states" was tested and fails: strip out New Orleans, Jackson, Memphis, Kansas City, Houston and the red-state gap survives. The honest concessions: yes, Chicago, Baltimore, and St. Louis have severe, persistent homicide problems; yes, some 2020-era progressive prosecutors went too far and several were recalled or defeated (Boudin in SF, Gascon in LA). But as a description of national crime or of who "defunded" whom, the talking point is mostly false — and by 2025, with murder at a 65-year low nationally, it's describing a country that no longer exists.
|
||
|
||
**Sources:**
|
||
1. [Cities vowed in 2020 to cut police funding — but budgets expanded in 2021 — NBC News, Dec 28, 2021](https://www.nbcnews.com/news/nbcblk/cities-vowed-2020-cut-police-funding-budgets-expanded-2021-rcna9864)
|
||
2. [Defund the Police: City Budgets — Bloomberg, 2021](https://www.bloomberg.com/graphics/2021-city-budget-police-funding)
|
||
3. [A year after 'defund,' police departments get their money back — Chicago Tribune, Oct 11, 2021](https://www.chicagotribune.com/2021/10/11/a-year-after-defund-police-departments-get-their-money-back)
|
||
4. [Portland among U.S. cities adding funds back into police departments — PBS NewsHour](https://www.pbs.org/newshour/amp/nation/portland-among-u-s-cities-adding-funds-to-police-departments)
|
||
5. [Minneapolis approves $8M cut to police budget — Star Tribune via Police1, Dec 2020](https://police1.com/police-administration/articles/minneapolis-approves-8m-cut-to-police-budget-not-staffing-iapdVvzhtBMLlILN)
|
||
6. [The 21st Century Red State Murder Crisis — Third Way](https://www.thirdway.org/report/the-21st-century-red-state-murder-crisis)
|
||
7. [The Two-Decade Red State Murder Problem — Third Way](https://www.thirdway.org/report/the-two-decade-red-state-murder-problem)
|
||
|
||
---
|
||
|
||
### B9. "Obama/Biden deported more people / built the cages."
|
||
|
||
**Verdict:** MOSTLY TRUE — and the comparison cuts against Trump 2.0 more than his supporters realize.
|
||
|
||
**What's actually right about this (steelman):**
|
||
This is largely accurate history. Obama oversaw roughly 2.75–3 million formal ICE removals over FY 2009–2016 (peaking at 409,849 in FY 2012 — still ICE's single-year record), earning the "deporter in chief" label from immigrant-rights groups. Counting returns alongside removals, Obama's total repatriations exceeded 5 million. The chain-link "cages" were indeed built under Obama: CBP's Ursula processing facility in McAllen, Texas (opened 2014) and the Nogales, Arizona warehouse shelter were erected during the 2014 unaccompanied-child surge, and DHS Secretary Jeh Johnson toured them. The famous viral 2014 photos of children in chain-link enclosures are Obama-era (though some viral "2014" photos were mislabeled and actually from 2019). Biden, for his part, ran up ~4.4 million repatriations by early 2024 (removals + returns + Title 42 expulsions) — more than any single term since George W. Bush's second term — including 271,484 ICE removals in FY 2024, a 10-year high.
|
||
|
||
**Key facts:**
|
||
- ICE removals by fiscal year: FY2009: 389,834; FY2010: 392,862; FY2011: 396,906; FY2012: 409,849 (record); FY2013: 368,644; FY2014: 315,943; FY2015: 235,413; FY2016: 240,255 — [ICE removal statistics, compiled from ICE annual reports](https://www.ice.gov/statistics)
|
||
- In FY 2016, 85% of all DHS removals and returns were recent border crossers; of interior removals, 90%+ had serious-crime convictions — [MPI, "The Obama Record on Deportations"](https://www.migrationpolicy.org/journal/policy-beat/obama-record-deportations-deporter-chief-or-not)
|
||
- Obama deliberately shifted from informal "voluntary returns" to formal removals with legal consequences, cutting border recidivism from 29% (FY2007) to 14% (FY2014) — [MPI](https://www.migrationpolicy.org/journal/policy-beat/obama-record-deportations-deporter-chief-or-not)
|
||
- The Nogales chain-link warehouse shelter was built by the Obama administration in 2014 during the unaccompanied-minors surge — [LA Times](https://enewspaper.latimes.com/infinity/article_share.aspx?guid=2751db17-fa3c-4e10-9435-7a1fed6bbd44); [Congressional hearing record, July 10, 2019](https://www.congress.gov/116/chrg/CHRG-116hhrg37284/CHRG-116hhrg37284.pdf)
|
||
- PolitiFact: chain-link enclosures "precede the Trump administration"; some viral "2014 cages" photos were actually from 2019 — rated False as labeled — [PolitiFact, Sept 9, 2020](https://politifact.com/factchecks/2020/sep/09/viral-image/photo-detained-child-migrants-2019-not-2014)
|
||
- Biden: 4.4 million repatriations through early 2024, incl. ~3 million Title 42 expulsions (most under Biden); 775,000 removed or returned in the 12 months after Title 42 ended — the most in any year since 2010 — [MPI, June 2024](https://www.migrationpolicy.org/journal/policy-beat/comparing-biden-and-trump-deportation-records)
|
||
- Trump 2.0 comparison: ~980,000 total deportations in 18 months (incl. border turnarounds and voluntary departures); annualized ~620,000 (FY2025) — *below* Biden's FY2024 total of ~685,000 and far below FY2000's all-time high of 1.86 million — [MPI, Oct 2026](https://www.migrationpolicy.org/publication/us-deportations-second-trump); [MPI, Oct 2025](https://migrationpolicy.org/commentary/new-era-immigration-enforcement-unfolds-us-interior-and-border-under-trump-20)
|
||
|
||
**Rebuttal / context to raise in conversation:**
|
||
The claim is basically true — so use it. Obama deported more people per year than any president before or since, built the 2014 chain-link facilities, and prioritized criminals and recent crossers. Biden expelled or removed ~4.4 million. Two honest caveats matter for the conversation. First, what distinguishes the Obama-era cages from Trump 1.0's 2018 policy isn't the fencing — it's family separation: Obama detained families together in emergency overflow; Trump's zero-tolerance policy deliberately split ~5,000+ children from parents as a deterrent, which is what made "kids in cages" a scandal rather than a logistics story. Second, the comparison undermines Trump's current branding: his FY2025 annualized deportation pace (~620,000) ran below Biden's FY2024 (~685,000), his interior-removal criminality rate (31%) is below the Obama–Biden average (44%), and ICE's all-time annual record (409,849 removals) still belongs to Obama. If someone's argument is "Democrats are open-borders radicals," the deportation ledger is the wrong exhibit.
|
||
|
||
**Sources:**
|
||
1. [The Obama Record on Deportations: Deporter in Chief or Not? — MPI](https://www.migrationpolicy.org/journal/policy-beat/obama-record-deportations-deporter-chief-or-not)
|
||
2. [ICE Enforcement and Removal Operations Statistics — ICE](https://www.ice.gov/statistics)
|
||
3. [Comparing the Biden and Trump Deportation Records — MPI, June 2024](https://www.migrationpolicy.org/journal/policy-beat/comparing-biden-and-trump-deportation-records)
|
||
4. [U.S. Deportations and "Self-Deportations" in the First 18 Months of the Second Trump Term — MPI, Oct 2026](https://www.migrationpolicy.org/publication/us-deportations-second-trump)
|
||
5. [Photo of detained child migrants is from 2019, not 2014 — PolitiFact, Sept 9, 2020](https://politifact.com/factchecks/2020/sep/09/viral-image/photo-detained-child-migrants-2019-not-2014)
|
||
6. [Kids in Cages hearing record — House Oversight, July 10, 2019](https://www.congress.gov/116/chrg/CHRG-116hhrg37284/CHRG-116hhrg37284.pdf)
|
||
7. [Why Deportations Were Higher Under Biden Than in Trump's First Term — NYT, Jan 22, 2025](https://www.nytimes.com/2025/01/22/us/trump-biden-immigrants-deportations.html)
|
||
|
||
---
|
||
|
||
### B15. "Democrats want open borders / sanctuary cities protect criminals."
|
||
|
||
**Verdict:** MOSTLY FALSE. Democrats negotiated and voted for the toughest border bill in decades in 2024 (Republicans killed it at Trump's direction); sanctuary policies limit cooperation with civil immigration detainers but do not shield anyone from criminal prosecution; and immigrants — including the undocumented — commit crimes at lower rates than the native-born. One honest caveat: declined ICE detainers have released some genuinely dangerous offenders.
|
||
|
||
**What's actually right about this (steelman):**
|
||
The strongest version of this claim: sanctuary jurisdictions genuinely do refuse ICE detainers at scale — ICE data shows 25,283 declined detainers from FY 2023 through Feb 6, 2025 (52% in California), including 72 people with homicide convictions or charges, and at least 17,864 detainers declined in the first 12 months of Trump's second term. Some of those releases ended in new crimes, and cases like Fairfax County's (1,670 detainers declined 2023–2025) are documented in congressional reports. Democratic-led cities did resist interior enforcement, and many Democrats opposed border-wall funding. If the claim is "sanctuary policies sometimes let deportable criminals walk out of local jails," that is TRUE.
|
||
|
||
**Key facts:**
|
||
- The 2024 bipartisan border bill (negotiated by conservative Sen. James Lankford, R-OK, with Murphy and Sinema) contained ~$20 billion for border security: 1,500 new CBP agents/officers, 1,200 ICE personnel, more detention beds, asylum officers, fentanyl screening, an end to "catch and release," fast-tracked asylum decisions, and presidential authority to shut down border sections when crossings surged — [NPR, Feb 4, 2024](https://npr.org/2024/02/04/1226427234/senate-border-deal-reached)
|
||
- The bill was endorsed by the Border Patrol union and the Chamber of Commerce; Trump publicly urged Republicans to oppose it; only 4 Republicans voted for cloture (failed 49–50, Feb 7, 2024; failed again 43–50 in May 2024) — [Congressional Record, Sen. Murphy, Feb 29, 2024](https://congress.gov/congressional-record/volume-170/issue-37/senate-section/article/S1055-3)
|
||
- Sanctuary policies generally mean local jails decline ICE detainers (requests to hold people up to 48h past release for pickup) or refuse release-date notifications — they do not prevent ICE from arresting anyone anywhere, and do not bar criminal prosecution or imprisonment of immigrants — [Hausman study summary, Washington Post via Congress.gov](https://www.congress.gov/119/meeting/house/118126/documents/HHRG-119-JU01-20250409-SD013-U13.pdf)
|
||
- Hausman (Stanford, 2010–2015 data): sanctuary policies cut deportations of nonviolent offenders by ~one-third but produced no increase in crime; violent offenders continued to be deported at the same rate — [Congress.gov record of WaPo reporting](https://www.congress.gov/119/meeting/house/118126/documents/HHRG-119-JU01-20250409-SD013-U13.pdf)
|
||
- County-level study (Social Science Research, 2022): sanctuary counties saw post-adoption *declines* in crime; no significant difference vs. non-sanctuary counties — [Congress.gov hearing record](https://www.congress.gov/118/meeting/house/116200/documents/HHRG-118-JU01-20230713-SD002.pdf)
|
||
- Declined detainers: 25,283 (FY2023–Feb 2025); California 13,025; 72 people with homicide convictions/charges released; 17,864 declined in Trump's first 12 months back — [CIS analysis of ICE data, Apr 2025](https://www.congress.gov/119/meeting/house/119516/documents/HHRG-119-JU01-20260901-SD029-U29.pdf); [House Judiciary report, Oct 20, 2026](https://judiciary.house.gov/sites/evo-subsites/republicans-judiciary.house.gov/files/evo-media-document/10-20-2026-fairfax-county-virginia-the-dangerous-consequences-of-sanctuary-policies.pdf)
|
||
- NIJ-funded study of Texas DPS records (2012–2018): undocumented immigrants were arrested for violent crimes at less than half the native-born rate (96.2 vs 213 per 100k), drug crimes at less than half (135 vs 337.2), property crimes at about a quarter (38.5 vs 165.2); homicide arrest rate less than half the native-born rate — [NIJ, Sept 12, 2024](https://docs.house.gov/meetings/JU/JU01/20250122/117827/HHRG-119-JU01-20250122-SD004.pdf)
|
||
- Cato analysis of Texas convictions 2013–2022: homicide conviction rate 2.2 per 100k for illegal immigrants vs 3.0 for native-born (26% lower); overall conviction rate 685 vs 1,321 per 100k (48% lower) — [Cato Institute](https://www.cato.org/policy-analysis/illegal-immigrant-murderers-texas-2013-2022)
|
||
|
||
**Rebuttal / context to raise in conversation:**
|
||
"Democrats want open borders" survived until February 2024, when Democrats signed onto a Lankford-written bill so conservative that the Border Patrol union endorsed it — and Republicans killed it, explicitly because Trump wanted to keep the border as a campaign issue (his own words at the time urged them to oppose it). Four Republicans voted yes. Whatever else is true, "Democrats refuse to secure the border" is not the lesson of 2024. On sanctuary cities: the policy is a refusal to hold people past their release date on a civil immigration request — a practice several federal courts found violates the Fourth Amendment when done without a warrant. No sanctuary policy stops ICE from arresting anyone, stops prosecution, or frees anyone from prison early. The empirical record (Hausman; county-level studies) shows no crime increase from sanctuary adoption. The honest concession: declined detainers are real, 25,000+ in ~2.5 years, and a small number involved people later charged with serious crimes — that tradeoff is worth arguing about. But the crime-rate floor under the whole talking point is wrong: the best state-level data in the country (Texas, the only state that tracks immigration status at arrest) shows undocumented immigrants offending at half or less the native-born rate across violent, drug, and property crime — confirmed by both the DOJ's research arm and the Cato Institute. Sanctuary cities aren't protecting criminals so much as declining to do a federal agency's civil-enforcement job — and the immigrants they decline to hand over are, statistically, less criminal than the citizens next door.
|
||
|
||
**Sources:**
|
||
1. [Senate negotiators reach bipartisan deal on border policy — NPR, Feb 4, 2024](https://npr.org/2024/02/04/1226427234/senate-border-deal-reached)
|
||
2. [Sen. Murphy floor speech on the killed border bill — Congressional Record, Feb 29, 2024](https://congress.gov/congressional-record/volume-170/issue-37/senate-section/article/S1055-3)
|
||
3. [Undocumented Immigrant Offending Rate Lower Than U.S.-Born Citizen Rate — NIJ, Sept 12, 2024](https://docs.house.gov/meetings/JU/JU01/20250122/117827/HHRG-119-JU01-20250122-SD004.pdf)
|
||
4. [Illegal Immigrant Murderers in Texas, 2013–2022 — Cato Institute](https://www.cato.org/policy-analysis/illegal-immigrant-murderers-texas-2013-2022)
|
||
5. [Study finds no crime increase in sanctuary cities — WaPo study summary in House record](https://www.congress.gov/119/meeting/house/118126/documents/HHRG-119-JU01-20250409-SD013-U13.pdf)
|
||
6. [Do sanctuary policies increase crime? Contrary evidence — Social Science Research (2022), in House record](https://www.congress.gov/118/meeting/house/116200/documents/HHRG-118-JU01-20230713-SD002.pdf)
|
||
7. [Which Sanctuary Jurisdictions Have Released the Most Criminals? — CIS, Apr 9, 2025 (in House record)](https://www.congress.gov/119/meeting/house/119516/documents/HHRG-119-JU01-20260901-SD029-U29.pdf)
|
||
8. [Fairfax County: Dangerous Consequences of Sanctuary Policies — House Judiciary interim report, Oct 20, 2026](https://judiciary.house.gov/sites/evo-subsites/republicans-judiciary.house.gov/files/evo-media-document/10-20-2026-fairfax-county-virginia-the-dangerous-consequences-of-sanctuary-policies.pdf)
|
||
|
||
---
|