3.9 KiB
Research Standards (read before writing any entry)
Purpose
A reference document the user consults mid-conversation when someone repeats a common Trump-supporter talking point. The goal is ACCURACY, not negativity. If a claim is true or partly true, say so clearly and cite it. If it's false or misleading, rebut it with overwhelming specificity.
Time scope
Trump's second term (Jan 20, 2025 – present, today is late October 2026) is primary. Bring in first-term (2017–2021) context where relevant.
Source hierarchy (strict)
- Primary/government: CBP/DHS data, BLS, BEA, CBO, Federal Reserve, Treasury, GAO, court filings/opinions, Congressional Record, official financial disclosures (OGE Form 278e), SEC filings, FEC, inspector-general reports, official transcripts.
- Wire services and nonpartisan fact-checkers: AP, Reuters, Bloomberg, PolitiFact, FactCheck.org, Snopes (for specific debunks), CRS reports.
- Major mainstream outlets: NYT, WaPo, WSJ, CNN, NBC, CBS, ABC, Politico, Axios, The Hill, Forbes (for wealth figures), ProPublica, NPR, BBC.
- AVOID: opinion pieces, editorials, and heavily partisan outlets (Fox opinion, MSNBC opinion, Daily Wire, Breitbart, Daily Kos, HuffPost opinion, Raw Story, etc.). Exception: if outlets on BOTH sides report the same fact, you may cite both.
- Nothing goes in without a working citation. If you can't source it, leave it out and note the gap.
Specificity rule (critical)
Vague summaries are rejected. Every rebuttal must carry concrete numbers, names, dates, dollar amounts, and document references.
- BAD: "Donald Trump Jr. has made millions from government contractors while his father was president."
- GOOD: "Donald Trump Jr. joined the board of Unusual Machines (NYSE: UMAC), a drone-parts maker, in Nov 2024, receiving 331,580 shares (~$4M at the time). UMAC's Army contracts: [specifics]. He joined the advisory board of Polymarket's parent in [date] and the board of 1789 Capital-backed [X]. Compare: Hunter Biden's Burisma compensation was ~$1M/year 2014–2019 per Senate HSGAC/Finance report (Sept 2020), total roughly $4M–$11M depending on the accounting." Give the per-person, per-deal breakdown wherever possible.
Entry format (use exactly)
[ID]. "[Claim as supporters phrase it]"
Verdict: TRUE / MOSTLY TRUE / MIXED / MOSTLY FALSE / FALSE / UNPROVEN
What's actually right about this (steelman): [Honest paragraph. If the claim is true, this is the main section. Cite.]
Key facts:
- [fact with number/date] — Source name
- [fact] — Source
- (6–12 bullets typical; more is fine if warranted)
Rebuttal / context to raise in conversation: [Several paragraphs. Specific. Overwhelming where warranted. Written so the user can nearly read it aloud. Include comparisons to the relevant Democratic equivalent where the talking point invites one, with the same level of specificity on both sides.]
Sources:
Verdict discipline
- "Border crossings at historic lows" → likely TRUE/MOSTLY TRUE. Say so plainly and cite CBP monthly encounter data.
- Don't manufacture a "but" where none is warranted. Don't soften a FALSE where evidence is clear.
- Note when data is contested or when the honest answer is "both sides have a point."
Working method
- Use web_search and web_extract liberally. Pull actual numbers from the actual pages.
- Verify URLs resolve. Prefer linking the specific page/report, not a homepage.
- For wealth/compensation figures, cite the disclosure form, SEC filing, or Forbes/Bloomberg analysis by name and date.
- When citing fact-checkers, link the specific fact-check.
- Where a number has changed over time (e.g., monthly border encounters), give the latest available and the trend.
Output
Write your assigned entries into the single markdown file path given in your task. Finish with a short "Gaps / could not verify" list at the end of the file.